B
y Dr. Alastair Muir, iSixSigma Contributing WriterHuman resources is no different than any other aspect of a business in being able to deliver Six Sigma projects with significant financial benefits to the company. Projects are directed toward the internal customer by conducting human resources functions faster and more efficiently, or toward the external customer by contributing to the ongoing transformation of the company toward achievement of a well functioning Six Sigma program.
Project Selection
There is never any shortage of Six Sigma projects in an organization. One of the most important first tasks is to identify the best projects. The most effective human resources (HR) Six Sigma projects are ones that focus on the external customer and are in sync with the strategic goals of the business.
In the book The Strategy-Focused Organization, authors Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton introduced "The Balanced Scorecard" to make business strategy a continuous process owned by all aspects of an organization. It presented four perspectives for examining a business starting with an external focus and moving internally.
- Financial Perspective – If we succeed, how will we look to our shareholders?
- Customer Perspective – To achieve my vision, how must we look to my customers?
- Internal Perspective – To satisfy my customers, at which processes must we excel?
- Learning and Growth Perspective – To achieve my vision, how must our organization learn and improve?
Cost Center Versus Business Unit
During the early days of adoption of Six Sigma at GE, Jack Welch sent a memo to all employees stating that Six Sigma was an integral and essential component of leadership development. This emphasized the learning and growth perspective of Kaplan and Norton, and it seemed that involvement of human resources in Six Sigma at GE was restricted to training and certification administration.
A typical view of human resources is that of an organization focused on the learning and growth perspective, essentially a cost center with an internal focus. Six Sigma can assist in identifying areas that have an impact on the external customer. These projects may concentrate on such aspects as leadership selection and training, enabling employees to focus on the external customer by decreasing their non-value added time, and organizational development to promote an effective Six Sigma culture. An effective Six Sigma program must identify high potential employees, hire them as Black Belts and move them back into the organization as part of their rotation and leadership training.
Some Warnings
Human resources professionals must gather and analyze their own data rather than obtain a list of projects from another part of the organization and apply them to the HR business focus. As a first step, a stakeholder analysis should be conducted to help identify potential areas of resistance to the project. The emphasis on objective data analysis seen in Six Sigma projects can run contrary to the data confidentiality culture of human resources. When resistance is found, it is usually political or power-based resistance to any project with an "HR Six Sigma" label. Senior stakeholders will tend to steer the Black Belt to projects where the stakeholders' solution is part of the project description. To prepare for this, time should be taken to conduct an objective analysis of how the project will make an impact on the key business indicators in the upper strategic goals of the company. An effort must be made to include the stakeholders' input. If they do not wish to participate, leadership should present the rigor used to select and evaluate potential projects.
In most Six Sigma human resources projects, the data required is confidential and personal. The members of the Six Sigma team must insure that:
- The team will not use the data in a punitive manner.
- The team will not use the data to identify areas to cut costs and eliminate jobs.
- The data is kept absolutely confidential. The team may require legal assurances to assert this.
Where to Look
When reviewing an human resources organization, it becomes clear that a number of business processes have an impact on the effectiveness of employee efforts in delivering services or products to customers. An effective HR organization can balance the financial needs of the company while attracting and retaining the most appropriate personal to become part of the organization.
The table below offers a logical grouping of HR functions with a sample of Six Sigma project opportunities. The list can be used to kickoff a brainstorming session with stakeholders and team members.
| Compensation and Benefits | Examples of Projects |
| Payroll administration Job evaluation Time and attendance management Medical/dental benefits Leave time eligibility, application and administration Merit pay design Stock option Profit sharing | OT authorization compliance Faster performance review for merit recommendations Benchmarking profit sharing with competitors Automatic paycheck deposit Eligibility for employee stock option plan (ESOP)
|
| Human Resources Management | Examples of Projects |
| New acquisition integration HR information services (payroll information, employee dependents, etc.) | Process mapping and risk management of acquisition integration process Consolidation of employee information databases Integration of multiple payroll systems for remote locations |
| Labor Relations | Examples of Projects |
| Absenteeism Conflict dispute resolution Discipline/termination/dismissal Discrimination Harassment Health Interpersonal communication Outplacement Safety Union negotiations Drug and alcohol | DFSS process design for discipline/termination/dismissal Job design and negotiation for outplacement Website development for executive communication with employees Discrimination and harassment compliance audit and monitoring
|
| Legal Issues | Examples of Projects |
| Firing Privacy of personal information Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Employee handbook publication | Accurate tracking of FMLA eligibility with secure internal website FAQ section of employee handbook for answering common queries
|
| Organizational Development | Examples of Projects |
| Career and succession planning Change management Communication programs Competencies Diversity Employee satisfaction Job design – telecommuting Leadership Organizational culture Performance improvement Workplace planning | Company wide employee satisfaction survey via internal website, publication of results and posting of ongoing improvement plans and results Identification of needs of diverse workforce Workgroup design for customized customer service delivery Electronic performance review for consolidation of reviews from remote sites
|
| Staffing and Selection | Examples of Projects |
| Contingent workers Employee contracts Exit interviews Recruitment Relocation Retention Selection Outsourcing Security and background checks | Increase job posting hit rate Design of job posting templates for recruiters Increase retention using exit interview information Decrease number of days to respond to applicant Use of technicians for some functions performed by engineers Decrease use of full security checks when not necessary
|
| Training | Examples of Projects |
| Design and development Delivery Training evaluations New employee orientation Management training and administration (internal certification) Compensation for external education | Improved learning module design with self-evaluation sections Catalog of available modules for self-learning
|
| Workplace Health and Safety | Examples of Projects |
| Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Insurance claims Drug expenses | 100% use of off-site safety audits Approved generic drug list
|
About the Author
Alastair Muir is president of Muir & Associates Consulting, Inc. He was the principal Six Sigma consultant for GE Power Systems for more than five years and has worked with thousands of quality professionals from the CEO level to hourly staff in all GE businesses at worldwide locations. Dr. Muir, who lives in Calgary, Canada, has several degrees including a Ph.D. He can be reached at lean@muir-and-associates.com.
